PERSONAL PREFERENCES BECOME EVERYBODY'S RULES
The difference between biblical conviction, Christian liberty, and spiritual pride
Be discerning. Think biblically. Examine everything in the light of God's Word. And be careful when your personal preferences begin to sound like commandments for everybody else.
One of the subtle dangers in Christian living is confusing what God has commanded with what we have personally come to prefer. It is possible to become so attached to our traditions, habits, convictions, and familiar ways of doing things that we begin treating them as though they carry the authority of Scripture.
But our preferences are not God's commandments. Our traditions are not automatically biblical principles. And our personal opinions do not become divine instructions simply because we hold them strongly.
Something can be different from your way without being disobedient to God. Something can make you uncomfortable without being sinful. And another believer can exercise a freedom you would personally choose not to exercise without necessarily dishonoring the Lord.
The Bible must be our authority, not our upbringing, personality, traditions, comfort, or personal taste.
This does not mean weakening biblical convictions to accommodate everybody. God's Word is not negotiable. Where Scripture speaks clearly, we must stand firmly. Where Scripture grants liberty, we must be careful not to impose restrictions God Himself has not imposed.
That is the balance of biblical discernment: conviction without arrogance, freedom without selfishness, and truth expressed through love.
1. Don't confuse your convictions with God's commandments.
Before correcting another believer, take a moment to examine your own heart.
Ask yourself:
- Does Scripture actually forbid this, or do I simply dislike it?
- Is this a biblical command, or a personal conviction?
- Am I defending God's truth, or protecting my own traditions?
- Am I helping someone grow in Christ, or demanding that everyone conform to my preferences?
These are important questions because religious pride can disguise itself as spiritual maturity.
A person can be very particular about outward appearances while neglecting the inward qualities God values most. Someone can be passionate about defending a tradition and surprisingly indifferent toward humility, patience, forgiveness, mercy, and love.
Jesus confronted precisely this vary problem when religious leaders elevated their traditions above God's commandments.
"For laying aside the commandment of God, you hold the tradition of men." Mark 7:8 NKJV
Think about that. It is possible to become so preoccupied with maintaining religious practices that we lose sight of the very Word we claim to defend.
A tradition may be meaningful, beneficial, and worth preserving. But it must never be elevated above Scripture.
Never give a human preference the authority that belongs exclusively to God's Word.
2. Romans 14: The biblical answer to disagreements over disputable matters.
One of the clearest passages addressing this problem is Romans 14.
The church in Rome included Jewish and Gentile believers who had different religious backgrounds and consciences. Although united in Christ, they disagreed about certain practices, particularly food and the observance of special days.
Some believers felt free to eat all foods. Others abstained from certain foods because of their consciences. Some regarded particular days as especially sacred, while others regarded every day alike.
Instead of extending grace, some began judging one another.
Those who understood their freedom looked down on those with stricter consciences. Those with stricter convictions condemned those who exercised greater freedom.
The disagreement exposed something deeper than differences of opinion: pride, judgmentalism, and a failure to love fellow believers.
Paul addressed the problem directly:
"Receive one who is weak in the faith, but not to disputes over doubtful things." Romans 14:1 NKJV
Notice Paul's instruction: receive one another.
He was not telling the church to abandon sound doctrine, tolerate immorality, or overlook false teaching. He was addressing matters in which Scripture allowed room for differing personal convictions.
The issue was not whether biblical truth mattered. The issue was whether believers had the humility to distinguish God's requirements from their own preferences.
What were these disputable matters?
Paul specifically discussed:
- Food: Some ate freely, while others abstained from certain foods (Romans 14:2–3).
- Special days: Some regarded particular days as sacred, while others regarded every day alike (Romans 14:5–6).
- Wine: Paul discussed voluntarily abstaining when its use might cause another believer to stumble (Romans 14:21).
These examples concerned matters of conscience, not permission to disregard God's moral commands.
The precise reasons behind every individual's convictions are not fully explained in the text. Jewish dietary practices and concerns about food associated with idolatry provide relevant historical background, but we should distinguish what Scripture explicitly says from what we reasonably infer.
The enduring lesson is clear:
God does not authorize us to turn every personal conviction into a universal requirement for His people.
3. Remember whose servant your fellow believer actually is.
Paul asks a question that should humble every Christian who is tempted to become judgmental:
"Who are you to judge another's servant? To his own master he stands or falls." Romans 14:4 NKJV
Consider the significance of that statement.
Another Christian belongs to Jesus Christ. He or she is accountable to the Lord, not ultimately to your personal expectations.
You are not that person's master. You are not the final authority over another believer's conscience. And you have not been appointed to make everyone else a reflection of yourself.
Of course, Scripture commands us to exercise discernment, lovingly confront genuine sin, restore those who have fallen, and guard the church against false teaching.
Galatians 6:1 instructs spiritual believers to restore someone caught in sin with a spirit of gentleness, while watching themselves.
There is a difference between biblical correction and personal criticism.
Correction seeks restoration. Condemnation often seeks superiority.
Correction is governed by Scripture and love. Personal criticism can be governed by irritation, pride, jealousy, or a desire to control.
Before you correct someone, make certain you are addressing something God has actually addressed.
Jesus gave us a necessary warning:
"And why do you look at the speck in your brother's eye, but do not consider the plank in your own eye?" Matthew 7:3 NKJV
We should be far more interested in examining our own hearts than finding something to criticize in everybody else's.
4. Christian liberty is not permission to sin, and personal preference is not biblical law.
There are three important categories Christians must learn to distinguish.
First: Biblical commands.
These are matters God has clearly addressed. We have no authority to rewrite them, disregard them, or accommodate sin because obedience becomes inconvenient.
Second: Biblical prohibitions.
Where God forbids something, Christian liberty cannot make it permissible. Calling disobedience freedom does not change its nature.
Third: Matters of Christian conscience and liberty.
These are areas in which Scripture does not establish a universal prohibition or requirement. Believers must exercise wisdom, conscience, and love.
This third category is where Romans 14 becomes especially important.
However, conscience is not infallible. A conscience can be weak, misinformed, or improperly shaped. It must continually be instructed by God's Word.
Paul develops this principle further in 1 Corinthians 8–10. He explains that although believers may possess freedom, love must govern how that freedom is exercised.
"All things are lawful for me, but all things are not helpful." 1 Corinthians 6:12 NKJV
Freedom is not an invitation to selfishness.
A mature Christian does not merely ask, "Can I do this?"
He also asks, "Is this even wise at all? Is it helpful? Does it honor Christ and the Bible? Could it unnecessarily harm someone else?"
The goal of Christian liberty is not to do everything we are permitted to do. It is to honor Christ in everything we choose to do.
5. Love people without approving of everything they do.
We must never confuse loving people with approving of their behavior.
God commands us to love people, including those whose actions are corrupt, dishonest, cruel, or deeply wrong.
But Christian love is never an excuse to call evil good.
Paul writes:
"Abhor what is evil. Cling to what is good." Romans 12:9 NKJV
That is the balance.
We can hate corruption without hating the person committing it. We can oppose injustice without becoming unjust ourselves. We can confront dishonesty without becoming dishonest in our own conduct.
Jesus commands us to love our enemies (Matthew 5:44). That includes people who mistreat us, misrepresent us, oppose us, or disagree with us.
Love does not eliminate discernment. It governs how we exercise it.
Neither should we become so consumed with exposing everyone else's faults that we neglect the condition of our own hearts.
"Let all bitterness, wrath, anger, clamor, and evil speaking be put away from you, with all malice." Ephesians 4:31 NKJV
We are to live with integrity, humility, purity, and a clear conscience before God and people.
Being above reproach does not mean being sinless. It means conducting ourselves with integrity, refusing to make excuses for sin, and maintaining a life that does not bring legitimate reproach upon the Gospel.
Never allow someone else's wrongdoing to become an excuse for your own un-Christlike behavior.
6. The stronger believer must know when to lay down a freedom.
Paul takes the subject beyond simply allowing differences.
He teaches that Christian freedom must be exercised with consideration for others.
"Therefore let us not judge one another anymore, but rather resolve this, not to put a stumbling block or a cause to fall in our brother's way." Romans 14:13 NKJV
Imagine a Christian who has no personal struggle with a particular activity. Another believer, however, associates that activity with a former sinful lifestyle and feels genuine temptation when exposed to it.
The mature believer should not pressure the other person to violate his conscience.
Paul teaches that love sometimes means voluntarily restricting something we are otherwise free to do.
This is not weakness. It is Christlike consideration.
However, there is another side to this teaching. A believer with a restrictive conscience must not automatically impose that restriction upon everyone else.
We should not pressure someone into violating conscience, but neither should we allow every personal objection to become a universal rule.
There is a difference between respecting another person's conscience and surrendering biblical liberty to another person's preferences.
Paul summarizes the principle:
"For the kingdom of God is not eating and drinking, but righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit." Romans 14:17 NKJV
What a needed reminder!
The Christian life is about far more than winning arguments over secondary matters.
Our lives should reflect the character of Christ.
7. Christian unity is not uniformity.
One of the great misunderstandings in church life is the assumption that unity requires everyone to think alike about every detail.
It does not.
Biblical unity is not the absence of every difference. It is a shared commitment to Jesus Christ, His Gospel, His Word, and the love He commands.
John Wesley expressed this beautifully in his sermon Catholic Spirit:
"Though we cannot think alike, may we not love alike?"
That is a profound question for the modern church.
Wesley was not suggesting that truth is unimportant or that doctrine should be compromised. He was addressing differences of opinion and worship that need not destroy Christian affection.
He understood that believers can disagree in certain matters without becoming enemies.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, in Life Together, likewise warned against loving an idealized picture of Christian community more than the actual people God has placed within it.
His observation is often rendered:
"The person who loves their dream of community will destroy community, but the person who loves those around them will create community."
That is a searching thought.
Sometimes we love our expectations of people more than we love the people themselves. We want everyone to fit our preferences, meet our standards, share our opinions, and approach life exactly as we do.
But Christian fellowship requires something deeper.
It requires learning to love real people, with their differences, weaknesses, growing faith, and individual personalities, while continuing to hold one another accountable to Scripture.
John Wesley's question deserves to be repeated:
Though we cannot think alike, may we not love alike?
And Paul's instruction remains:
"With all lowliness and gentleness, with longsuffering, bearing with one another in love, endeavoring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace." Ephesians 4:2–3 NKJV
8. Do not let secondary disagreements distract you from the Great Commission.
There is something profoundly tragic about Christians spending more time criticizing one another than reaching people who desperately need Jesus.
Think about it.
People around us are struggling with guilt, broken relationships, addiction, hopelessness, spiritual confusion, and the consequences of sin. Many have never clearly understood the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
Yet Christians can become so occupied with debating secondary matters that they neglect their greater responsibility.
Jesus did not commission His church to make everyone adopt our personal preferences.
He commanded us to make disciples.
"Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit." Matthew 28:19 NKJV
The church must never sacrifice biblical truth for superficial harmony. But neither should it sacrifice love, fellowship, and its Gospel witness over matters God has left to Christian conscience.
Paul writes:
"Therefore let us pursue the things which make for peace and the things by which one may edify another." Romans 14:19 NKJV
The word pursue is important.
Peace and spiritual encouragement require intentional effort. Sometimes that means listening instead of arguing, extending patience instead of criticism, and choosing to build someone up instead of proving a point.
We have enough genuine spiritual battles without manufacturing unnecessary ones among fellow believers.
Let us spend less time policing personal preferences and more time proclaiming the Gospel, making disciples, encouraging the hurting, restoring the fallen, and helping people follow Jesus.
9. Seven questions every Christian should ask before judging someone else.
Before criticizing, correcting, or confronting another believer, honestly examine your own heart.
-
Is this clearly addressed in Scripture? Am I defending a biblical command or merely my personal preference?
-
Am I confusing tradition with truth? Have I elevated something familiar to me into a requirement God never established?
-
Have I considered the whole counsel of God? Am I interpreting Scripture in its proper context rather than using isolated verses to support my opinion?
-
Is my motivation genuinely loving? Am I seeking restoration and spiritual growth, or am I trying to establish my superiority?
-
Am I willing to extend the same grace I want others to extend to me? Do I remember my own shortcomings?
-
Am I exercising my freedom responsibly? Could my conduct unnecessarily tempt or spiritually harm another believer?
-
Will my response build someone up or merely create another argument? Am I helping someone become more like Christ?
These questions are not an invitation to compromise biblical truth. They are an invitation to practice biblical truth with humility.
James reminds us:
"Therefore, my beloved brethren, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath." James 1:19 NKJV
Sometimes the most spiritually mature thing we can do is listen carefully, examine ourselves, open God's Word, and refuse to turn a personal disagreement into a spiritual battle.
THE BOTTOM LINE: BE UNCOMPROMISING IN TRUTH AND GENEROUS IN GRACE.
Christian maturity requires knowing the difference between what God commands and what we personally prefer.
Stand firmly for the Gospel. Defend biblical truth. Reject sin. Exercise discernment. Never compromise the authority of Scripture simply to avoid disagreement.
But where God has granted liberty, do not become a lawgiver. Where believers differ in conscience, do not become their judge. Where correction is necessary, speak the truth with gentleness and love.
Do not confuse your preferences with God's principles, your traditions with His commandments, or your opinions with biblical truth.
You are called to follow Jesus, not to make everybody else a copy of yourself.
The goal is not to win every disagreement. It is to honor Christ in every circumstance.
The goal is not to control everyone else's conscience. It is to help one another grow in the knowledge and grace of Jesus Christ.
The goal is not unity at the expense of truth, nor truth wielded without love. It is a church firmly grounded in Scripture, characterized by holiness, humility, genuine love, and a shared commitment to the Gospel.
Jesus gave His disciples a distinguishing mark:
"By this all will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another." John 13:35 NKJV
That is a testimony worth protecting.
Be firm where God is firm. Be gracious where God grants liberty. Be humble enough to examine yourself. And be loving enough to put another person's spiritual well-being ahead of your own preferences.
After all, we will never glorify the Lord by insisting that everyone do things our way. We glorify Him by faithfully doing things His way.
"Let all that you do be done with love." 1 Corinthians 16:14 NKJV
May our convictions be governed by Scripture, our attitudes shaped by Christ, our consciences informed by God's Word, and our relationships marked by the love of Jesus. Come as you you are, repent, believe.. willing to be changed by God. KnowGod.org
No comments:
Post a Comment